The Weinstein Company /Courtesy Everett Collection
Feeling bewildered by the smorgasbord of content on Netflix? Or perhaps you actually wish there were more choices?
When it comes to films, many of us often find ourselves battered by the algorithmic déjà vu, as we keep seeing the same titles suggested ad nauseam.
In a quest to alleviate that dreaded âwhat to watch nextâ sensation, the Watch With Us team diligently curates the finest cinematic offerings available on the platform each month, zeroing in on those that have charmed critics, as evidenced by their high Rotten Tomatoes scores.
For September 2025, here are some comedies, dramas, documentaries, and other gems you shouldnât miss on Netflix.
5. âMay Decemberâ (2023)
This melodrama from famed director Todd Haynes, known for Carol, delves into the complex topics of sexuality, power, and the insatiable hunger for sensationalism in a film thatâs as tightly wound as it is darkly comical. Here we find Natalie Portman portraying actress Elizabeth Berry, whoâs invited to embody the role of infamous pedophile Gracie Atherton-Yoo (brought to life with unsettling charm by Julianne Moore). To better understand her character, Elizabeth ventures to Georgia to engage with Gracie and her husband Joe (Charles Melton), whom Gracie was convicted of raping when he was a mere 13 years old while she was 36.
As she immerses herself in their lives, the dynamics unravel, prompting Joe to confront uncomfortable truths about his identity and family. Portman delivers a potent balance of malevolence and innocence, while Meltonâs performance reveals an inner conflict that will leave audiences reeling.
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 91 percent
4. âOne of Them Daysâ (2025)
Sometimes life seems to throw everything but the kitchen sink at you. Who hasnât felt the sting of a day going spectacularly wrong? Picture this: your roommateâs boyfriend swipes your rent money, and now youâre frantic to scrape together enough cash to avoid eviction, all while gearing up for your biggest job interview ever. While perhaps not everyone has experienced this precise chaos, youâll definitely find a kindred spirit in Dreaux (Keke Palmer) and Alyssa (SZA) as they race through a hilariously manic day in Los Angeles.
One of Them Days elegantly blends elements reminiscent of Friday, Bridesmaids, and Insecure. With an ensemble featuring surprise appearances from Lil Rel Howery, Katt Williams, and Maude Apatow, this vibrant film showcases Palmerâs unflinching charm and marks a stellar acting debut for SZA. The camaraderie between these two roommates forms the comedic core that keeps audiences engaged.
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 94 percent
3. âSing Streetâ (2016)
What happens when a fib you spun to impress a crush spirals into the best decision of your life? Thatâs exactly the predicament faced by 15-year-old Conor (Ferdia Walsh-Peelo) when he claims that the model Raphina (Lucy Boynton) should star in a music video for his non-existent band. Conor suddenly finds himself compelled to create said band to woo her, sparking connections with new friends amidst the backdrop of 1980s Dublinâs economic strain and melancholy atmosphere.
The band adopts the name âSing Street,â a nod to the suffocating Christian Brothers school they attend. This cinematic gem, directed by John Carney of Once fame, deftly captures their quest for artistic expression and rebellion against authority, delivering humor and joy along with a delightful soundtrack. Truly one of the essential films from the 2010s.
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 95 percent
2. âAre You There God? Itâs Me, Margaretâ (2023)
We simply canât get enough of this classic!
Almost every girl across the United States grew up immersed in Judy Blumeâs beloved novel, Are You There God? Itâs Me, Margaret. Adapting such a monumental piece for the screen was no small feat, yet director Kelly Fremon Craig has truly captured its essence. Keeping pivotal moments from Margaret Simonâs life (Abby Ryder Fortson)âfrom first crushes to inexplicable identity shakesâFremon Craig seamlessly expands narratives for characters like Margaretâs mother, Barbara (Rachel McAdams).
This charming film, complemented by a stellar â70s soundtrack and genuine performances, marks an essential viewing for all. Despite its coming-of-age theme, its heartfelt execution resonates across generations.
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 99 percent
1. âA Secret Loveâ (2020)
If you missed this documentary during the isolation of April 2020, consider it an opportunity lost. The film, expertly produced by Ryan Murphy and Jason Blum, chronicles the inspiring journey of two elderly womenâTerry Donahue, a former star of the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League, and her partner, Pat Henschelâwho finally reveal their love to Terryâs family after over 60 years together.
As they face the complexities of aging and societal prejudice, their enduring love shines through, enveloping the audience in warmth and sincerity. A Secret Love stands as a testament to loveâs strength, successfully earning its place among critical favorites.