By this point, itâs hard to ignore the recent release from pop sensation Taylor Swift, whose latest album has taken the music world by storm.
(If you somehow havenât caught wind of this groundbreaking event, I must admit, I envy your isolation from the pop culture cacophony.)
Last Friday, the 35-year-old Swift launched her new album titled âThe Life of a Showgirl,â and, true to form, it quickly achieved commercial acclaim.
According to Billboard, âShowgirlâ racked up over 3 million âtraditional albumâ sales, which, amusingly, diminishes in scale next to a staggering 300 million on-demand streams its songs received.
Chances are, that one relentless Taylor Swift aficionado in your social circle is now fully immersed in her latest collection of tunes.
However, should that aficionado propose introducing their young daughter to âShowgirl,â it might be prudent to step in, as a wave of concerned Christian mothers on social media have already begun voicing hesitation after a brief review of the albumâs lyrics.
âThese are some sample lyrics from Taylor Swiftâs new album,â shared Christian author and podcaster Haley Williams on her Substack. âIâve seen mothers bringing their six-year-old daughters to album launch parties, yet eight out of the twelve songs on âThe Life of a Showgirlâ contain explicit content, marking a significant increase in profanity compared to her previous works. But evidently, Christian women are eager to share this with their little ones! Because #beats and #vibes.â
âLetâs delve into whatâs hiding beneath those upbeat rhythms for your precious kiddos.â
Williams meticulously dissected several lyrics from Swiftâs recent tracks, and suffice it to say, they leave much to be desiredâboth in terms of artistry and appropriateness for a younger audience.
From the song âWoodâ:
Forgive me, it sounds cocky
He ah-matized me and opened my eyes
Redwood tree, it ain’t hard to see
His love was the key that opened my thighs
From âFather Figureâ:
Iâll be your father figure, I drink that brown liquor
I can make deals with the devil because my dickâs bigger
This love is pure profit, just step into my office
Theyâll know your name in the streets
(Williams emphasized on Instagram: âWe cannot guide our children toward righteous paths and then be surprised when they stray.â)
Those two examples are merely a glimpse, but they encapsulate the stark transition from the innocent pop of her earlier days to the risqué expressions that now populate her discography. Can we truly champion this as a role model for young girls?
Conservative author and commentator Allie Beth Stuckey certainly doesnât think so:
âAlright, moms, your daughters should steer clear of Taylor Swift,â Stuckey asserts. âShe hardly fits the bill as a role model. It actually mystifies me that some Christian moms contend sheâs a better influence than Chappell Roan. Seriously, if thatâs our standard, weâre operating with the bar laid painfully low.â
âThereâs a notable difference between the experiences of todayâs teenagers listening to Swift and those of my generation when Taylor was a teen among us. Back then, she was singing about the trivialities of youthful romancesânot the explicit themes one now encounters.â
âAs parents, we are entrusted with the stewardship of our childrenâs upbringing.â
Indeed, that responsibility weighs heavily.
In fact, prior to âShowgirl,â my assessment of Swiftâs music could best be summarized as largely inoffensiveâthough to clarify, inoffensive does not inherently denote âgood.â Her sound was a formulaic pop concoction familiar to those of us raised in the â90s.
However, following the release of âShowgirlâ? Now, the kindest observation one could muster would be that, at least, Swift penned the lyrics herself?
Williams perhaps encapsulated the sentiment perfectly: âThe album overall lacks edification and certainly isnât something Christian mothers should endorse for their daughters. It makes sense that the world would embrace this, but it utterly baffles why a Christian audience would.â
This article originally appeared on The Western Journal.