Bishop Ronald Hicks is stepping into a challenging situation as he takes on the leadership of the Archdiocese of New York amidst the ongoing sex abuse scandal within the Catholic Church. There are concerns about how he will approach the $300 million settlement negotiated by his predecessor, Timothy Cardinal Dolan, for victims of child sex abuse.
Advocates for victims of clergy abuse are wary of Bishop Hicks’ stance on addressing the issue, especially given the history of cover-ups within the Church. Attorney Mitchell Garabedian, known for exposing the clergy sex abuse scandal in Boston, expressed doubts about Bishop Hicks’ commitment to helping survivors heal.
Despite the financial challenges faced by the Archdiocese, including significant property sales to fund settlements, Bishop Hicks emphasized the importance of accountability, transparency, and healing in addressing the abuse crisis.
Concerns have been raised by advocacy groups that the change in leadership could impact ongoing settlement negotiations with abuse victims. The Coalition for Just & Compassionate Compensation wrote to Pope Leo XIV expressing fears that the transition could disrupt the mediation process.
Attorney Jeff Anderson, representing hundreds of victims, highlighted the ongoing mediation process and the lack of a finalized settlement agreement. He acknowledged the challenges faced by the Church in litigation battles and expressed hope for resolution with the new leadership.
Additional reporting by Georgett Roberts

