What You Think You Know About Crime In Cities Is Wrong-USDOJ | Crime in America.Net

Highlights

This article is available as a podcast on YouTube.

Research indicates that a significant majority of violent and property crimes occurring in urban areas go unreported to law enforcement.

Statistically, only 13 percent of rape and sexual assault incidents are reported to police in urban settings, leading to a vast majority of perpetrators not facing arrest or prosecution.

The challenge of accurately counting crime stats resembles navigating the wild west of sociology. While many media narratives suggest a decline in crime, credible reports indicate that crime remains a serious issue in cities.

Findings from the National Crime Victimization Survey show substantial increases in rates of violence.

Are we providing the public with the complete picture regarding crime in America?

Explore Crime in America.Net’s “Top 10 Sources for Crime in America” that rely on primary statistical data and trustworthy secondary analyses.

Author

Leonard Adam Sipes, Jr.

Former Senior Specialist for Crime Prevention and Statistics at the DOJ Clearinghouse, former Director of Information Services at the National Crime Prevention Council, and retired federal spokesperson. Leonard has decades of experience in public relations focused on crime and statistics, authoring several works and consulting for high-profile campaigns.

Crime in America.Net – “Trusted Crime Data, Made Clear.”

The site has been referenced by major outlets such as The Associated Press, USA Today, and various academic and governmental entities, showcasing a commitment to transparent and accurate crime data reporting.

Subscribe for updates on new articles directly through our website.

A thorough analysis of crime trends from recent years can be found at Violent and Property Crime Rates In The U.S.

Article

Recent debates surrounding crime statistics in Washington, D.C., and across various American cities reveal a dichotomy in perception among reporters and pundits, many of whom assert that crime rates are on the decline based on published FBI statistics. However, this assertion is challenged by the reality that the majority of crimes never reach the ears of law enforcement.

According to the US Department of Justice’s Bureau of Justice Statistics National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), about 38% of violent incidents in urban settings are reported to authorities.

Thus, it is plausible that violent crime is on the rise, in contrast with the FBI’s reported slight reduction in violence in their latest report for 2024.

New Insights from the Bureau of Justice Statistics on Reporting Crime

This discussion stems from a new analysis by the Bureau illustrating the extensive gap in crime reporting to law enforcement.

Considerations

Fear of Crime: Nationally, levels of fear surrounding crime are soaring. Approximately 65 percent of Washington D.C. residents reported crime as a serious issue in recent surveys, despite claims of declining violence. An AP-NORC poll further revealed that 68% of respondents consider crime a significant issue in large cities.

The National Crime Victimization Survey in its 2023 report indicated a historical rise in violent crime (44 percent), per analysts like Jeff Asher and The Marshall Project. Estimates suggest violent crime continues at rates similar to those of 2022, making it one of the most prominent upticks ever recorded.

Conclusion

The portrayal of crime in American urban areas is largely derived from incomplete reporting data, neglecting significant increases in violence highlighted by the NCVS, while simultaneously overlooking widespread public fear regarding crime.

Bureau of Justice Statistics Analysis of Reported Crimes

Recent findings reveal that about 38% of violent offenses in urban environments were communicated to police, contrasting with suburban (43%) and rural (51%) reporting rates. Alarmingly, the percentage of rape and sexual assaults reported (13%) in urban areas is dramatically lower than those in rural (52%) and suburban (29%) communities.

When examining property crimes, only 25% of recorded incidents in urban regions were reported to authorities, which reflects a similar trend of underreporting compared with suburban (33%) and rural (36%) areas. Given that property crimes account for about 80% of total criminal activity, this underscores the alarming extent of unreported crime in cities.

Additional Notes

The Bureau aggregates multi-year data for precision, but should be noted that individual year findings may vary significantly. Additionally, this discussion does not delve into allegations of cities misrepresenting crime data, though accusations have surfaced, such as the scrutiny faced by Oakland, CA, and Washington, D.C.

While numerous factors contribute to an individual’s choice to report crimes, historical evidence suggests victims often regard violent crimes as personal matters or believe that law enforcement cannot meaningfully address property crimes.

For an elucidation on what defines urban areas, a comprehensive definition is available in the appendix.

Final Thoughts

Providing clarity around crime data collection presents a complex challenge that extends beyond the scope of this article. For additional, more detailed information, refer to Violent and Property Crime in the US.

While it may be challenging to assert the accuracy of our current assessment of reported crime, it is misleading—and perhaps unethical—to overlook the significant increases in violence acknowledged by the National Crime Victimization Survey, as well as the rising public fear regarding crime noted in various polls.

This discussion also overlooks substantial reports indicating significant rises in property crimes, including a reported 33% increase in cybercrime losses as of 2024. Yet, contrasting with the available evidence, the FBI has issued reports suggesting a decline in property crimes.

Counting and interpreting crime is dauntingly complex, but current media narratives often portray crime as declining based on a slim dataset of reported crimes, despite mounting evidence suggesting persistent crime challenges faced by many citizens, highlighted by the NCVS’s reports of escalating violence rates and widespread public concern. Are we genuinely facilitating an honest discourse with the American populace on crime?

Utilizing ChatGPT for Verification

ChatGPT assisted in fact-checking various aspects of this article, specifically regarding the proportionality of simple assaults in relation to overall violent crime and the analytic particulars noted above.

Defining Urban Areas Per the Bureau of Justice Statistics

The Bureau of Justice Statistics adopts the classification frameworks as delineated by the U.S. Census Bureau and the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for the publication of crime and victimization statistics.

Typically, BJS designates urban areas as any territory, population, and housing units situated in urbanized areas (with populations exceeding 50,000) and urban clusters (with populations ranging from 2,500 to 49,999).

Privacy Policy

Your personal information is not collected. For more details, please see our privacy policy at About This Site.

Explore More

Delve into additional articles focused on crime and justice at Crime in America.

For insights on the most dangerous cities/states/countries, visit Most Dangerous Cities.

To investigate US crime rates, see Nationwide Crime Rates.

For information on national offender recidivism rates, check Offender Recidivism.

Stay updated on latest news and announcements from Crime in America.Net through our RSS feed at https://crimeinamerica.net/?feed=rss2.