Friday, 10 Oct 2025
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • DMCA
logo logo
  • World
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Economy
  • Tech & Science
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • More
    • Education
    • Celebrities
    • Culture and Arts
    • Environment
    • Health and Wellness
    • Lifestyle
  • 🔥
  • Trump
  • VIDEO
  • House
  • White
  • ScienceAlert
  • Trumps
  • Watch
  • man
  • Health
  • Season
Font ResizerAa
American FocusAmerican Focus
Search
  • World
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Economy
  • Tech & Science
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • More
    • Education
    • Celebrities
    • Culture and Arts
    • Environment
    • Health and Wellness
    • Lifestyle
Follow US
© 2024 americanfocus.online – All Rights Reserved.
American Focus > Blog > Economy > Can a Constitution Limit the State?
Economy

Can a Constitution Limit the State?

Last updated: July 21, 2025 9:00 am
Share
Can a Constitution Limit the State?
SHARE

In the realm of political philosophy, a significant rift exists between James Buchanan and Anthony de Jasay regarding the feasibility of crafting a constitution that effectively limits state power and mitigates its inherent dangers. This debate is not merely academic; it echoes throughout the thoughts of numerous classical liberals and libertarians, including Friedrich Hayek. However, the contrasting positions of Buchanan and de Jasay stand out, showcasing two distinct interpretations rooted in a common economic framework: neoclassical, subjectivist, non-utilitarian, informed by public choice theory, and critical of “social choice.” Buchanan’s theories, shaped significantly by the American constitutional experience, resonate particularly well in the United States, although their implications extend universally. De Jasay’s critique of Buchanan is thorough, warranting serious consideration rather than a hasty dismissal.

Buchanan posits that it is indeed possible to establish institutions that restrain the state within boundaries acceptable to all citizens. These boundaries are defined by rules that everyone agrees upon, akin to a virtual social contract. Here, each individual recognizes that a peaceful society—contrary to Hobbes’ notion of a chaotic “war of all against all”—serves their self-interest, provided they are not subjected to exploitation by others. This realization underpins the necessity for a state to enforce the social contract and prevent itself from becoming a tool of oppression. The constitution, in this framework, fulfills this role. With each individual holding a veto power—the flip side of unanimity—there exists a collective awareness that all must consent to the foundational social contract and constitutional framework to enjoy the benefits of social interaction. This collective understanding curtails the risk of dissenters, even though the agreed-upon rules may permit side payments to those who might believe their situation under anarchy would be preferable.

See also  South Carolina State University campus on lockdown after reported shooting

(For those interested, essential readings on this topic include Buchanan’s The Limits of Liberty and his co-authored work with Geoffrey Brennan, The Reason of Rules.)

Conversely, Anthony de Jasay challenges the validity of the social contract concept, deeming it a mere illusion devoid of practical utility. He argues that public goods can either be supplied through private means or should not exist at all. The notion of achieving unanimous agreement on general rules is, in his view, a pipe dream, as it necessitates consensus on the unpredictable outcomes related to wealth redistribution. De Jasay contends that the belief in a constitution’s capacity to effectively restrict state power is nothing more than optimistic naivety. The regime of social choice—characterized by non-unanimous decisions imposed on the populace—emerged from constitutional frameworks cannot remain contained. He warns that democratic politics will inevitably give rise to redistributive coalitions that seek to extract greater financial benefits and privileges from the government at the expense of their fellow citizens. Consequently, entitlements and “public goods” will expand uncontrollably. When a simple majority (50% plus one) desires a constitutional change, it can achieve this, often through reinterpretation of existing rules. Even qualified majorities cannot safeguard against this, as enough members can be lured to change their allegiance. Under a democratic system, the prevailing constitution becomes one of majority dominance over an unbounded arena.

(For a deeper exploration of this perspective, see my review of de Jasay’s Against Politics on Econlib, or better yet, Chapter 2 of the book.)

Historical observations of American constitutional evolution over the past century and a half, alongside the current rapid decline in constitutional constraints, certainly lend credence to de Jasay’s arguments. Similar narratives can be drawn from French constitutional history and the British model of unwritten constitutions. Nevertheless, the anarchist ideal is not without its own complexities.

See also  Zoltraak: Competition versus Stagnation - Econlib

Curiously, at times, Buchanan and de Jasay appear to find common ground through the uncertainties each has about their respective theories. De Jasay has expressed that he would be pleased if Buchanan’s assertion—that the state can indeed be constrained—holds true (see my Regulation review of de Jasay’s Justice and Its Surroundings). Buchanan has noted that the growing desire among many (if not most) individuals to be treated like children by the state suggests that the “thirst or desire for freedom and responsibility may not be as universally held as many Enlightenment thinkers have posited” (“Afraid to Be Free: Dependency as Desideratum,” Public Choice, 2015).

******************************

The chained guard dog, by ChatGPT

The chained guard dog, by ChatGPT

TAGGED:ConstitutionlimitState
Share This Article
Twitter Email Copy Link Print
Previous Article Morgan Stanley hires Shahsingh from UBS to head North American industrials banking Morgan Stanley hires Shahsingh from UBS to head North American industrials banking
Next Article Illicit ‘fight club’ busted at LI swim center after gunfire breaks out — leading to 13 arrests Illicit ‘fight club’ busted at LI swim center after gunfire breaks out — leading to 13 arrests
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Popular Posts

17 Flowy Wide-Leg Jumpsuits That Visually Slim Larger Thighs

If you're on the hunt for a stylish yet comfortable outfit that's easy to throw…

June 26, 2025

Kings League’s success explained: How Gerard Pique’s project has become a popular new style of soccer

The Kings League, founded by former FC Barcelona defender Gerard Pique in 2022, has quickly…

January 13, 2025

Antibiotic resistance predicts higher mortality risk in 17-year follow-up—linked to diet and gender

Antibiotic resistance is a growing concern worldwide, with more than one million deaths attributed to…

July 15, 2025

Mase Says He’s Debating Going To Diddy Trial, Asks Public To Vote

Mase Should I Go To Diddy's Trial??? Published May 2, 2025 5:21 PM PDT |…

May 2, 2025

All Blacks thrash Japan 64-19

The All Blacks kicked off their end-of-season tour in style, scoring 10 tries to secure…

October 26, 2024

You Might Also Like

This Analyst Just Hiked Their UnitedHealth Stock Price Target by 50%. Should You Buy UNH Now?
Economy

This Analyst Just Hiked Their UnitedHealth Stock Price Target by 50%. Should You Buy UNH Now?

October 10, 2025
Why Is Wolfspeed Stock Soaring Today?
Economy

Why Is Wolfspeed Stock Soaring Today?

October 10, 2025
When Godzilla Breaks Windows
Economy

When Godzilla Breaks Windows

October 10, 2025
Peter Schiff Describes Bitcoin’s Jump Over 6,000 As ‘Bear Market Rally’: ‘Too Early For Bitcoiners To Get Excited…’
Economy

Peter Schiff Describes Bitcoin’s Jump Over $126,000 As ‘Bear Market Rally’: ‘Too Early For Bitcoiners To Get Excited…’

October 10, 2025
logo logo
Facebook Twitter Youtube

About US


Explore global affairs, political insights, and linguistic origins. Stay informed with our comprehensive coverage of world news, politics, and Lifestyle.

Top Categories
  • Crime
  • Environment
  • Sports
  • Tech and Science
Usefull Links
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • DMCA

© 2024 americanfocus.online –  All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?