However, the university maintains that there is no specific timeline for tearing down the structure.
The Archway Lecture Theatres, consisting of four interconnected spaces designed in 1974 by the late Ted McCoy of McCoy and Wixon Architects, have long been recognized as a significant example of brutalist architecture on the campus, enduring for over 50 years.
The future of the theatres is uncertain following the University of Otago’s appeal to the Environment Court to overturn the heritage protection status granted by the Dunedin City Council through the district plan.
This approach by the university has angered Genevieve Robinson, whose father, Lou Robinson, collaborated with Mr. McCoy on the project as an engineer.
‘‘Lou dedicated his life to defending structures that others dismissed — churches, mills, bridges, homes — because he believed in the richness they add to our landscapes.
‘‘With both he and McCoy now gone, they cannot defend this work,’’ she said.
Genevieve, currently residing in Christchurch, argued that claims the building is no longer ‘‘fit for purpose’’ are baseless.
She has initiated a petition to protect the building, which has already gathered over 600 verified signatures.
As an Environment Canterbury councillor, she expressed her frustration over the apparent lack of public engagement regarding the building’s future.
‘‘Experts agree that this project needs saving for various reasons, not just for the portfolio of buildings we have, but because it marks a significant shift in educational architecture,’’ she noted.
Her father was just 30 years old when the building was designed, and she feels that the decision to demolish it overlooks its historical significance.
‘‘Dad only passed away last year, and I think no-one has considered the other people involved in that original project.
‘‘Ted McCoy and my father were not only business partners but also great architects and engineers.’’
Her mother, Sandra Robinson, also expressed disappointment at reaching this point.
‘‘Brutalism might not be traditionally beautiful, but it is iconic. It’s more than just a building,’’ she remarked.
According to Otago University chief operating officer Stephen Willis, the university had indicated plans to remove the building as part of its 2010 campus master plan.
‘‘However, it is important to note that there is currently no timeline or approved plan for the demolition of the building, so no formal consultation has been undertaken to date,’’ he stated.
‘‘The situation arose because the Dunedin City Council was considering adding the Archway Lecture Theatres to the heritage schedule, which would have limited future options for the buildings.’’
Mr. Willis emphasized the need to consider other factors.
The university possesses more building space than it requires and can maintain, and the Archway Lecture Theatres are the least favorable of the 19 tiered lecture theatres on campus, with the likelihood of being unused in the coming years.
