Uncovering the Mystery of Impossible Black Holes
In 2023, gravitational wave detectors detected a collision 7 billion light-years away, where two black holes had merged in a spectacular explosion of warped spacetime. However, upon closer analysis, astronomers made a startling discovery – these black holes were spinning at unprecedented speeds and fell within a mass range where black holes were not supposed to exist.
Typically, when massive stars reach the end of their lives, they collapse and explode as supernovae, leaving behind black holes. Stars within a specific mass range, approximately 70 to 140 times the mass of the Sun, are expected to undergo pair instability supernovae, resulting in the complete annihilation of the star with no remnant left behind.
The collision, known as GW231123, challenged this fundamental rule as both black holes involved had masses that placed them in this forbidden zone and were spinning at near-light speeds, distorting spacetime around them like whirlpools.
Revealing the Role of Magnetic Fields
Previous theories speculated that these black holes could be second-generation ones formed from earlier mergers, but the process usually disrupts the spin. The discovery of two massive, fast-spinning black holes colliding seemed improbable until Ore Gottlieb and his team at the Flatiron Institute’s Center for Computational Astrophysics considered the role of magnetic fields.
The team’s simulations followed a giant star, 250 times the Sun’s mass, through its life cycle. By the time the star collapsed, it formed a spinning disk of stellar material laced with magnetic fields, ejecting half the star’s mass away at nearly light speed due to the pressure exerted by the magnetic fields. This process significantly reduced the final mass of the black hole, placing it in the forbidden mass gap while also affecting its spin rate.
Implications and Future Research
The simulations showed that stronger magnetic fields result in lighter, slower-spinning black holes, while weaker fields lead to heavier, faster-spinning ones. This relationship suggests a pattern linking the mass and spin of black holes, providing new insights into how these cosmic entities form.
Furthermore, the research predicts that such formations should produce observable gamma-ray bursts, offering a means to test these theories and determine the prevalence of these “impossible” black holes in the universe.
Overall, the study sheds light on the mysterious phenomenon of impossible black holes and opens up new avenues for understanding these enigmatic cosmic entities.
This article was originally featured on Universe Today. Read the original article here.

