Mom of Slain Postal Worker Blasts Plea Deal for Son’s Killer
The mother of a postal worker who was fatally stabbed in a Manhattan deli expressed her outrage on Wednesday over prosecutors’ decision to allow the perpetrator to plead guilty to first-degree manslaughter and receive a 15-year prison sentence. Ada Rice, the grieving mother, criticized the plea deal, fearing that the killer, Jaia Cruz, would be released early and pose a threat to society once again.
Jaia Cruz, 24, admitted to fatally stabbing USPS postman Roy Hodge at Joe’s Deli Grocery in Harlem on January 2. The plea deal was reached just months after Cruz was indicted on a second-degree murder charge, which carries a maximum sentence of 25 years to life.
Rice was taken aback when Manhattan Assistant District Attorney Elizabeth Clerkin informed the court that Cruz expressed remorse and wished to take responsibility for Hodge’s death, despite the family’s strong opposition to the plea deal. Rice also revealed that she was initially assured by the DA’s office of a strong case, particularly citing a video from inside the deli showing the altercation between Cruz and Hodge.
Video Evidence and Emotional Courtroom Scenes
The video reportedly captures Cruz and Hodge engaging in a dispute after an incident at the deli counter, where Hodge allegedly cut in line ahead of Cruz. The altercation escalated, leading to Cruz stabbing Hodge multiple times, eventually causing his death. Prosecutors stated that Cruz showed no remorse, even declaring, “He deserved it,” as Hodge lay wounded on the ground.
During the court hearing, one of Hodge’s supporters had to be escorted out after vehemently protesting the plea deal, declaring it as unjust. The emotional outburst highlighted the deep sense of loss and frustration felt by the victim’s loved ones.
Legal Defense and Sentencing
Cruz’s attorney, Mitchell Schuman, had previously argued that Hodge was the aggressor in the altercation, claiming that video evidence showed him initiating physical violence against Cruz. Schuman also alleged that Hodge had verbally harassed Cruz with derogatory remarks before the confrontation turned violent.
As part of the plea agreement, Cruz will serve 15 years in prison for first-degree manslaughter and will also face five years of supervised release. The sentencing is scheduled for May 28, where Cruz’s fate will be determined.
Rice lamented the lack of federal charges against Cruz, emphasizing that her son, a federal employee, deserved justice at a higher level. Despite the plea deal, Rice remains determined to seek accountability and closure for the tragic loss of her son, Roy Hodge.
The mission of the U.S. Postal Inspection Service is to protect the U.S. Postal Service, secure the nation’s mail system, and ensure public trust in the mail. Founded by Benjamin Franklin, the U.S. Postal Inspection Service has a successful history of fighting criminals who attack and misuse our nation’s postal system.