The holiday season is here, and with it comes the joy of over-the-top cookie decorating. However, many cookie cutters seem to lose their context and leave users puzzled about their shapes. A subreddit called r/WhatIsMyCookieCutter has emerged as a community where members come together to decipher the mystery behind these unidentified cookie cutters. What started as a fun guessing game has turned into a creative outlet for users to propose imaginative and sometimes absurd interpretations of these odd shapes.
The subreddit, which gained popularity in 2022, has attracted over 350,000 weekly visitors and has become one of the more wholesome spaces on Reddit. Users engage in a guessing game where they come up with outlandish possibilities for the shapes of cookie cutters, complete with digital drawings to support their interpretations. Some shapes, once identified, turn out to be surprisingly simple, while others remain a mystery, sparking even more creativity among the community.
One example is a cookie cutter that was initially thought to depict an alligator flying out of an ice hole but turned out to be the shape of Finland. Despite the reality, users continue to let their imagination run wild. Another shape resembling a KitchenAid standing mixer led to a series of creative interpretations that showcased the community’s web-based creativity.
The subreddit has also developed its own set of tropes, including cats in bizarre poses, weed paraphernalia, Halloween ghosts, and even a user known as “rose guy,” who interprets every shape as a rose. These tropes have become memes within the community, adding to the fun and creativity of the subreddit.
Overall, r/WhatIsMyCookieCutter serves as a reminder that creativity can be found in the most unexpected places. It’s a space where users can come together, have a laugh, and exercise their creative thinking. Some users have even found the subreddit to be more inspiring for daily drawing than other art-focused communities.
In conclusion, the community of r/WhatIsMyCookieCutter shows us that creativity knows no bounds, and even the simplest of shapes can spark endless imagination. So, as we celebrate the holidays, may your iced cookies be as unique and creative as each of us.

