The Consequences of Banishing the Strong Gods

In a previous post, I explored R. R. Reno’s insights into the banishment of the strong gods and the ideas that drove this process. In this article, we will delve into the consequences of this societal shift.

One of the strong gods that were cast aside was the belief in the sacredness of communities and the individual’s responsibility to contribute to the well-being of the collective. Karl Popper criticized this notion as “magical” thinking that promoted “anti-humanitarian propaganda.”

Similarly, the rejection of strong truths, whether moral or factual, was seen as necessary to avoid fanaticism and atrocities. Embracing weaker, more flexible truths allows for critical examination and prevents blind loyalty to dogmatic beliefs.

Reno points out that modern society does not embrace absolute moral principles but instead encourages individuals to formulate their own interpretations of life’s meaning. This shift reduces the intensity of collective loyalties that often lead to conflict and oppression.

Traditionalists, who uphold strong respect for inherited traditions, have also been targeted for banishment in favor of promoting an open society that rejects the imposition of norms and restrictions.

However, the emphasis on personal meaning over unifying truths has its drawbacks. While it promotes individual autonomy, it lacks clear guidance on leading a meaningful life, leaving many adrift in a sea of subjective interpretations.

Reno warns that denying the value of inherited cultural traditions and promoting self-discovery can result in aimless wandering and a lack of fulfillment in life. The abandonment of strong norms leaves individuals without a roadmap for navigating the complexities of existence.

Furthermore, Reno highlights the discrepancy between the public advocacy for weak gods by intellectual elites and their private adherence to traditional values. This inconsistency raises questions about the sincerity of their beliefs and the impact of their actions on societal norms.

Ultimately, the rule of weak gods not only influences social dynamics but also has significant political implications. In the next post, we will explore Reno’s perspective on this aspect of the banishment of strong gods.