The 2025 year-end crime briefing from Commissioner Jessica Tisch highlighted the NYPD’s success in reducing crime rates across various categories, except for juvenile crime. Despite a significant decrease in murders, robberies, thefts, and burglaries, juvenile crime continued to rise.
One possible explanation for this concerning trend is the state’s 2018 Raise the Age law. This law raised the age of criminal responsibility to 18, leading to most 16- and 17-year-old offenders being redirected to Family Court where they often avoid harsh sanctions like jail time. As a result, juvenile crime has been on the rise, with a higher percentage of shooting victims and perpetrators being minors.
The increase in youth violence is not unique to New York City, as communities statewide are facing similar challenges. District attorneys have called for revisions to the Raise the Age law to address the surge in youth gun violence. However, the effectiveness of rehabilitation programs for juvenile offenders remains questionable, with limited evidence supporting their success.
Governor Kathy Hochul should focus on filling the gaps created by the Raise the Age law, rather than relying solely on rehabilitation programs. This could include giving judges access to a juvenile defendant’s full criminal history and prioritizing public safety considerations in court decisions. The goal should be to ensure that young offenders are held accountable for their actions while also receiving the necessary support for rehabilitation.
While some may argue against incarceration for teens, it is essential to consider the impact on the safety and well-being of young victims. The recent increase in serious violent felony arrests of juveniles underscores the urgency of addressing juvenile offending as a pressing issue. Albany should consider reforms to the Raise the Age law in the current legislative session to better balance rehabilitation with public safety.
Those advocating for a more lenient approach to juvenile crime should reflect on the consequences of their stance on teen victims. It is crucial to find a middle ground that holds young offenders accountable while also providing them with the resources they need to turn their lives around.
In conclusion, addressing juvenile crime requires a comprehensive approach that considers both rehabilitation and public safety. By acknowledging the shortcomings of the current system and implementing necessary reforms, New York can better protect its youth and communities from the impact of rising youth violence.
