The iconic St. Elmo Steak House in Indianapolis is at the center of controversy after former Jets quarterback Mark Sanchez was accused of a drunken attack on a grease truck driver. The restaurant, known for its upscale dining experience and celebrity clientele, is denying claims that it over-served Sanchez before the incident.
Perry Tole, the alleged victim, has filed a lawsuit against Sanchez and Fox Sports, claiming that the former quarterback was served alcohol while already visibly intoxicated at St. Elmo. The restaurant, a popular spot for NFL players and fans alike, has refuted these allegations and maintains that they did not contribute to the events that unfolded.
Sanchez, who was in Indianapolis for a football game, allegedly assaulted Tole in an alleyway, leading to a violent altercation that resulted in Tole stabbing Sanchez in self-defense. Tole claims to have suffered severe and permanent disfigurement as a result of the attack.
In response to the lawsuit, St. Elmo’s parent company, Huse Culinary, has filed a response denying any responsibility for the incident. The restaurant, known for its signature shrimp cocktail and premium steaks, has been a fixture in the Indianapolis dining scene for years.
Sanchez is facing criminal charges for the assault, including battery resulting in serious bodily injury and public intoxication. If convicted, he could face up to six years in prison and a hefty fine. His trial is scheduled for March, and he has since been fired from his position at Fox Sports.
The incident has brought unwanted attention to St. Elmo Steak House, a beloved establishment in Indianapolis. Despite the controversy, the restaurant continues to serve its loyal patrons and uphold its reputation for fine dining and impeccable service.

