Conservationists are sounding the alarm that key fish stocks in the UK may be on the verge of “imminent” collapse unless decisive measures are taken to address overfishing.
The charity Oceana UK is urging the British Government to align catch quotas with scientific recommendations to protect the traditional fish and chips, as their recent report indicates that many fish stocks are in a critical condition.
READ OUR INVESTIGATION: THE CATCH
READ: END OF THE LINE FOR COD?
READ: MACKEREL ‘AT RISK OF COLLAPSE’
The findings reveal that half of the UK’s top 10 commercial fish stocks are either critically depleted, experiencing overexploitation—fishing limits exceeding scientifically recommended levels—or both.
Critical Situation
North Sea cod, which scientists have recently suggested should have a “zero catch” this year to aid in its recovery, is currently suffering from extreme overfishing and diminished populations.
Other threatened species include the edible crab populations in the Southern North Sea, which are at critically low levels, alongside North Sea herring and North East Atlantic mackerel, both of which are being overfished.
The charity emphasized that overfishing is a “political choice.” They are calling on UK politicians to develop a sustainable management plan to preserve the marine ecosystem and the livelihoods of those within the fishing industry and coastal communities.
The report highlights that only two-fifths of the 105 UK commercial fish stocks assessed were found to be in good health.
This assessment, touted as one of the most thorough conducted since Brexit, identified that over a quarter of these stocks are overfished, leading to dangerously low populations.
Limits of Quotas
Moreover, a quarter of the stocks are being overexploited, with current quotas set above scientifically advised levels necessary for sustaining fish populations into the future.
<pAlarmingly, one in six stocks are both overfished and overexploited, according to the report.
In addition to North Sea cod, Celtic Sea cod, as well as herring and whiting in the Irish Sea, are recorded at critically low levels yet continue to be subjected to quotas that surpass scientific guidance.
However, recoveries of fish populations are achievable where scientific advice is heeded, stated Oceana UK’s executive director, Hugo Tagholm.
For instance, both West of Scotland haddock and North Sea plaice have been enjoying healthy populations since catch limits were set in accordance with scientific recommendations in 2020.
Long-term Prosperity
Mr. Tagholm pointed out that fish stocks are a “renewable resource” that can be sustained through proper management; neglect could lead to the extinction of certain species.
“If we continue on this path without implementing science-based strategies, the collapse of some of these stocks could be just around the corner. We want to ensure that these iconic species do not become relics of the past,” he stated.
“The fish and chip dinner is an iconic British meal cherished not only along coastal areas but throughout the entire country, and we must take steps to guarantee its continuation.”
He elaborated to the PA news agency, “Overfishing stems from political decisions made by ministers who are approving quotas and endorsing overfishing practices.
“It’s high time that the government establishes quotas at safe levels to ensure healthy fish populations, robust marine ecosystems, and thriving communities reliant on sustainable fish stocks for their ongoing well-being and food security.”
Strategy for Security
He urged for a “time-sensitive” strategy to end overfishing, adhere to scientific advice, and replenish fish stocks, while also advocating for measures such as banning damaging bottom trawling in protected marine areas.
Edward Baker, chief executive of the Plymouth Fishing and Seafood Association, emphasized that healthy marine environments are essential for a thriving fishing industry, and called for the government to prioritize sustainable local fisheries.
“If the science indicates a need to reduce fishing efforts, we must heed that advice—because a lack of fish directly threatens our industry and our communities’ future,” he asserted.
However, he noted that the industry requires governmental support to secure their livelihoods, ensuring that fishermen can continue to contribute to the UK’s food security.
Stock Viability
The report also points to regional differences in fish stock conditions, with 41 percent of stocks in the Celtic Sea reported as overfished—a rise from 27 percent in 2020—while one-third of stocks in the Irish Sea face critically low levels.
In contrast, the West of Scotland is in a healthier position, with only 12 percent of stocks overfished and 62 percent classified as healthy.
A spokesperson for the Environment Department (Defra) stated that the organization is collaborating with the fishing industry to promote British seafood and sustainably manage fish stocks, alongside launching a new ÂŁ360 million fisheries and coastal growth fund aimed at advancing the sector.
“We are dedicated to restoring our fish stocks to sustainable levels and have made noteworthy progress in the last five years while supporting the long-term viability of our domestic fishing industry,” the spokesperson added.
Author Information
Emily Beament is the environmental correspondent for the PA.
