Why Our Brains, Our Selves won the Royal Society science book prize

There’s a stereotype that science books authored by scientists can be tedious, dense, and academic. However, the shortlisted titles for the Royal Society Trivedi Science Book Prize debunk this myth, especially the winning entry: Our Brains, Our Selves by neurologist Masud Husain.

As the chair of a diverse panel of six passionate book lovers, including New Scientist news editor Jacob Aron, I had the privilege of participating in the challenging process of curating the shortlist and selecting the final winner. Our in-depth discussions reflected our passion for science and literature, and we explored many fascinating topics throughout.

Disagreements were common, yet always respectful, and this group displayed an exceptional ability to consider differing opinions. Our varying backgrounds and experiences enriched our understanding of the books we evaluated, as well as the act of reading.

This year’s entries included numerous outstanding science books, but Our Brains, Our Selves remarkably combined superb storytelling with rigorous and innovative science, all conveyed in an engaging manner that deeply resonated with its humanity. Husain, a neuroscientist and clinician, shares seven captivating patient narratives that form the core chapters of the book.

Among the various cases are individuals facing life-altering challenges—one suffers from profound apathy following a stroke, while another believes she is engaged in an affair with her husband. Each story reveals significant transformations, demonstrating how pathological brain issues can lead to dramatic personality shifts that result in social rejection.

At the heart of the book lies the examination of “self” and how the brain shapes our identities. The narrative is delivered with empathy and a personal lens, while the science—often derived from Husain’s own research—is presented clearly, acknowledging the gaps in our knowledge. I appreciate this approach; the most valuable science prompts curiosity and inspires further inquiry.

Utilizing case studies from clinical practice is a common method, but the nuance here stems from its deeply personal narrative. Have you ever felt like an outsider? These poignant stories compel readers to reflect on identity, self-perception, and the notion of belonging within society.

This theme resonated strongly with our panel. We pondered: what does belonging truly mean? Several individuals featured in the book belong to immigrant communities (including the author) who face challenges like prejudice and hostility in their quest for acceptance. In an increasingly interconnected world, it is disheartening to see our fears of diversity remain unaddressed.

Our Brains, Our Selves invites readers to consider how brain disorders can lead to profound changes in identity, yet also emphasizes the role of cognitive functions in defining who we are. Ultimately, our brain does shape our humanity. This compassionate work seamlessly imparts scientific knowledge while brimming with remarkable empathy.

Sandra Knapp is a plant taxonomist at the Natural History Museum, London, and chaired this year’s Royal Society Trivedi Science Book Prize judging panel. The winning title is Our Brains, Our Selves, a recent selection for the New Scientist Book Club.