The New Scientist Book Club took a departure from science fiction in October, opting for the winner of the Royal Society Trivedi Science Book Prize. The selected book, Masud Husain’s Our Brains, Our Selves: What a neurologist’s patients taught him about the brain, was praised for its exploration of how brain issues can impact a person’s sense of self. The book weaves together medical histories with Husain’s personal story of immigration, creating a compelling narrative.
While the judges lauded the book, our book club members had mixed reactions. Some found the exploration of self and brain conditions thought-provoking, especially in how it affects one’s identity and societal acceptance. Others appreciated the engaging writing style and interesting cases discussed in the book.
However, some members raised concerns about the contrived nature of the storytelling, particularly how patient dialogues and events were portrayed. The use of ornate language and excessive definitions of terms also drew criticism from a few readers. Additionally, the term “normal” when referring to brain conditions sparked a debate on what constitutes normalcy and how it can be perceived.
Despite these critiques, some members acknowledged the author’s passion for his work and the effort put into writing the book. Moving forward, the book club is set to explore Every Version of You by Grace Chan in November, a science fiction novel delving into the mysteries of the brain and virtual reality.
Topics:
