57
Middle school students thrive on independent thinking, and Would You Rather questions are a fantastic way to harness that energy. These questions serve as excellent conversation starters, writing prompts, or simply a chance for a good laugh or deep thought. This collection of both humorous and serious Would You Rather questions encourages middle schoolers to explore ideas about life, careers, and creative storytelling.
Fun and Funny Would You Rather Questions for Middle School
Would You Rather questions are among the most engaging writing prompts for middle school. They are great for initiating writing or discussions at the start of class and helping group members learn more about each other before embarking on a major project.
Would you rather…
- Be a hamburger or a bowl of soup?
- Never wear blue again, or only wear blue going forward?
- Eat one huge taco or a hundred tiny tacos?
- Live as a penguin in the zoo or a bird in the sky?
- Spend the day as a rabbit or a monkey?
- Go a week without showering or go a day without your cell phone?
- Be the main character in a romance movie or a comedy?
- Walk on your hands or eat with your feet?
- Never smell anything again or always smell terrible?
- Read your dog’s thoughts or have him read your thoughts?
- Have a song stuck in your head forever or never hear music again?
- Always be sunburned or always be sleep-deprived?
- Go bald or have a permanent mullet?
- Pass gas in front of the whole class or call the teacher “Mom”?
- Own a judgmental fish or a paranoid dog?
Use Would You Rather questions as bellringers or icebreakers
Looking for a way to kick off each class period? These Would You Rather questions for middle school cover an array of subjects, topics, and grade levels to inspire students.
100 Would You Rather Questions – Conversation or Writing Prompts – Icebreaker
By Real Cool English
Grades: 4th-8th
Subjects: Writing
With 100 engaging Would You Rather questions, you’ll have endless writing prompts at your disposal. This resource features both serious and funny questions on individual print and digital cards, offering an excellent way to break the ice in the first week of school or throughout the year.
Would You Rather – Slides for Icebreaker, Bellringer, & More!
By Mochas and Markbooks
Grades: 6th-12th
These 70 Would You Rather questions, available in PowerPoint and Google Slides, challenge middle schoolers to make decisions on engaging topics, fitting any classroom format.
Would You Rather Questions
By Reach All Readers – with Anna Geiger
Grades: PreK-12th
Subject: English Language Arts
With over 500 Would You Rather questions, this resource is suitable for students of all ages. Whether read aloud to younger students or handed out to older ones, these questions allow students to select one that resonates with them.
Middle School Would You Rather Questions About Life
Middle school life can be complex. Simplify their decision-making with Would You Rather questions that provide only two choices: This or That? These questions are perfect as journal prompts for 7th and 8th graders or any middle schooler needing a reflective moment.
- Talk to your family or your friends about your problems?
- Spend the day on the beach or in the forest?
- Eat pizza every day or never eat pizza again?
- Be in charge of ten kindergartners or one ten-year-old?
- Skip five years into the future or repeat five years of the past?
- Make your texts public or your search history public?
- Let your mom or your dad choose your clothes?
- Trade places with your friends or your teacher?
- Have plans every night or only have plans once a month?
- Vacation in another country or go to Disney World?
- Be friends with your parents or your grandparents when they were in high school?
- Only look amazing in selfies or only look amazing in group pics?
- Be an identical triplet or an only child?
- Have a bad picture of you go viral or have a great picture of you get deleted?
- Be remembered for something embarrassing or be ignored forever?
- Always be late or always be early?
- Stay up all night or go to sleep at 7 p.m.?
- Graduate high school at 16 or 20?
- Have friends wherever you go or only have 1-2 good friends?
- Be the best player on a losing team or the worst player on a winning team?
Incorporate Would You Rather questions into SEL activities
Would You Rather questions are ideal for social-emotional learning (SEL) lessons, helping students reflect on their priorities and feelings about various issues. Use these questions in SEL activities for middle school students to consider different aspects of their daily lives.
Would You Rather Worksheets for Mixed Groups
By The Speech Express
Grades: 5th-8th
Subjects: English Language Arts, Vocabulary
Enhance literary discussions and argumentative skills with these thought-provoking questions for middle schoolers. Students can work on inferences, text structures, multiple meanings, and more with worksheets focusing on speech and language skills for mixed groups and higher language goals.
Would You Rather Visual Game Slides
By Autism The Teen Years
Grades: 7th-12th
Pose the question “Would you rather?” to middle schoolers with 100 visual questions covering food, jobs, living environments, and relationships. Each question serves as an excellent bell ringer, reading prompt, or topic for small group discussions.
Job and Career-Focused Would You Rather Questions for Junior High
It’s never too early to consider future careers! Whether for 8th-grade sociology or college and career readiness, these This or That questions help middle schoolers reflect on how they feel about different job and career paths.
- Work outside or in an office?
- Spend a full hour doing work or take breaks every five minutes?
- Get a job in a restaurant or in a shoe store?
- Work with numbers or work with words?
- Have a boring job that makes a lot of money or have an exciting job that makes an average amount of money?
- Spend the day driving or spend the day cooking?
- Have an annoying boss or have your parent as your boss?
- Do something you love for long hours or something you hate for ten minutes?
- Have a job in the medical field or the teaching field?
- Work on a screen all day or work with people all day?
- Do the same job your parent does or take an unknown mystery job?
- Work in a big city or work on a farm?
- Be a famous actor or a famous athlete?
- Go to college or get a job right out of high school?
- Have the job you wanted as a kid or a job you think you want as an adult?
Include Would You Rather questions in a career exploration unit
These Would You Rather questions are perfect for guiding students to think about their future careers. With games, discussion prompts, journal ideas, and other activities, students can provide focused answers to these questions.
Would You Rather Activity for Career Exploration | Digital Game & Writing Pages
By KJ Inspired Resources
Grades: 5th-12th
Subjects: Classroom Community, School Counseling
Encourage students to think critically about their futures with a career exploration game, prompting them to consider work habits, life choices, and potential career paths.
Creative and Cool Middle School Would You Rather Questions
For those who love fantasy or sci-fi adventures, these Would You Rather questions will be a highlight. Use these debate topics to encourage creative thinking and spark ideas for future narrative writing assignments.
- Have mind reading powers or the ability to move things with your mind?
- Live in a tree or live underground?
- Be able to fly or be able to teleport?
- Have a portal that goes to another world or a ship that goes to outer space?
- Have a wish be granted by a genie or be a genie yourself?
- Be able to see the future or change the past?
- See a ghost or hear a ghost?
- Be a superhero or a supervillain?
- Shapeshift into an animal or into other people?
- Be friends with a dragon or be a dragonslayer?
- Live underwater or in space?
- Have feet that always dance or a voice that always sings?
- Be royal or be magical?
- Ride a pegasus or a T. rex to school?
- Be a huge giant or be a tiny elf?
Reinforce science skills with Would You Rather questions
Would You Rather questions aren’t just for English Language Arts. Incorporate these science-themed questions into your writing and discussion prompts for science class, and observe how they influence students’ choices based on the concepts from your unit.
Back to School SCIENCE GAME ACTIVITY Would You Rather? SCIENCE EDITION
By Flying Color Science
Grades: 6th-8th
Subject: Science
Offer a fresh perspective on scientific concepts with science-themed Would You Rather questions. These 108 question cards encourage students to engage in discussions, share opinions, or start class with intriguing “Brain Boosts” on NGSS concepts in earth science, physical science, and technology.
Give students choices that keep them engaged
The greatest advantage of Would You Rather questions for middle school is their ability to capture students’ attention. Whether they answer quickly or take a moment to think, the engagement is the key goal of any discussion or writing prompt. For a more advanced approach, consider adding Would You Rather questions for high school students to your middle school prompt collection.
