Tuesday, 10 Jun 2025
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • DMCA
logo logo
  • World
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Economy
  • Tech & Science
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • More
    • Education
    • Celebrities
    • Culture and Arts
    • Environment
    • Health and Wellness
    • Lifestyle
  • 🔥
  • Trump
  • House
  • White
  • VIDEO
  • ScienceAlert
  • Trumps
  • Watch
  • man
  • Health
  • Colossal
Font ResizerAa
American FocusAmerican Focus
Search
  • World
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Economy
  • Tech & Science
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • More
    • Education
    • Celebrities
    • Culture and Arts
    • Environment
    • Health and Wellness
    • Lifestyle
Follow US
© 2024 americanfocus.online – All Rights Reserved.
American Focus > Blog > Economy > What papal conclaves can teach democracies about voting
Economy

What papal conclaves can teach democracies about voting

Last updated: April 24, 2025 9:55 am
Share
What papal conclaves can teach democracies about voting
SHARE

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.

Hackers are a healthily sceptical crowd. As soon as they scrutinise a system, their instinct is to hack it. But even the most devious would struggle to hack one of the most secure voting systems yet devised: the method for selecting a new pope. After almost two millennia, the Catholic Church has come close to perfecting the art, according to Bruce Schneier, author of A Hacker’s Mind. What can we learn from the process?

We should first acknowledge that, like all elections, papal conclaves are contentious. There is often controversy as the likely candidates, or papabili as Vatican watchers call them, discreetly jostle for the favour of their fellow cardinals. The impression conveyed in Conclave, the best-selling novel by Robert Harris that was turned into an Oscar-winning film, is that papal elections are rife with intrigue, skulduggery and backroom deals. Historians suggest this is far from pure fiction.

Next month’s election has already stirred strong emotions, with the Maga Catholics in the US calling for a more “Trump-like pope” to reject the liberalism of the late Pope Francis. However, six of the 10 American cardinals who can vote were appointed by Francis and seem more attuned to his approach. In total, the Argentine pope appointed 108 of the 135 cardinals eligible to vote, which may strongly sway the outcome.

Even if controversies swirl about the direction of the Catholic Church and the composition of the all-male electoral college, the voting process itself is relatively uncontentious, having been codified over centuries. The voting cardinals, who come from all over the world and remain secluded during the conclave, write the name of their preferred candidate on a card and swear an oath at the altar of the Sistine Chapel every time they cast their ballot. Each round of voting is overseen by three randomly selected scrutineers. The sleeves of the cardinals’ choir dress are translucent lace (presumably to avoid any sleight of hand). Every vote is announced, no matter how time consuming. Several rounds are often needed to reach a definitive result.

See also  Voting Has Never Been More Secure Than It Is Right Now

Schneier suggests three lessons can be drawn from the papal process. First, every step of the electoral system is transparent to all participants even if the votes are secret. Second, small and simple elections among known voters are less vulnerable to manipulation. Third, when a selection process evolves over a long time it can become “surprisingly good”.

There are plenty of small-scale elections that can be conducted in similar, if less elaborate, ways but secure votes are difficult at large scale, particularly when technology is involved. “There is no such thing as secure voting that is purely digital,” Schneier says. That point is proved each year at the Def Con conference, where hackers regularly expose the flaws of the latest US digital voting systems.

The challenge of holding secure ballots is particularly acute in the US given the scale of elections and the range of issues presented to voters. That makes automation essential even if risky, according to Matt Blaze, a professor at Georgetown University who researches electoral integrity.

However, Blaze suggests there is a way to minimise automation risks. Physical ballot papers (including postal votes) remain essential but they can be recorded and counted electronically using optical scan technology. That automation process can then be checked using a sampling technique known as risk-limiting audits. “I am optimistic that we can have very high-integrity elections even with the monstrous ballots we have in the US,” Blaze tells me.

There are far broader threats to democracy than imperfect voting mechanisms: rabble-rousing politicians such as Donald Trump who refuse to accept legitimate results; AI-enabled manipulation and disinformation; and foreign interference, among others. But, even here, the history of papal elections can be instructive given how adaptive they have been. “Papal conclaves do everything they can to ensure that the people voting and the people observing think the process is fair. Democracies have a lot to learn from this,” says Gina Neff, executive director of the Minderoo Centre for Technology and Democracy.

See also  Is Robinhood Markets, Inc. (HOOD) The Best Stock To Buy and Hold For 10 Years?

Over many centuries, papal contests have been pockmarked by bribery, intimidation, riots, schisms and extended wrangling: the papal election of 1268 lasted two years and nine months. It has taken good faith, constant adaptation and effective verification mechanisms to improve the process. With luck, hackers can help the rest of us get there faster today by flagging risks and proposing safer solutions in voting systems around the world.
john.thornhill@ft.com

TAGGED:conclavesdemocraciesPapalTeachVoting
Share This Article
Twitter Email Copy Link Print
Previous Article Slashing NASA’s Programs Will Squander America’s Place in Space Slashing NASA’s Programs Will Squander America’s Place in Space
Next Article EconLog Price Theory: Gas Shortages EconLog Price Theory: Gas Shortages
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Popular Posts

Where to watch Serbia vs. Spain: UEFA Nations League live online, TV, prediction and odds

Spain's national team is set to kick off their UEFA Nations League campaign against Serbia,…

September 5, 2024

England vs. Greece odds, prediction, pick: Nations League live stream, TV channel, start time, team news

Group B2 of the Nations League is really starting to heat up, with two unbeaten…

October 9, 2024

Colorado ski resorts have above average snow, powder to start season

Thanks to a series of recent storms blessing most of the Colorado high country, ski…

November 11, 2024

All the Red Carpet Looks From the 2025 WNBA Draft

The 2025 WNBA Draft is set to take place at The Shed in New York…

April 14, 2025

Esther Art Fair Returns to a Beaux Arts Architectural Gem

The second edition of Esther, known as Esther II, is currently taking place at the…

May 8, 2025

You Might Also Like

US says it struck framework deal with China to restore trade war truce
Economy

US says it struck framework deal with China to restore trade war truce

June 10, 2025
Advance Auto Parts, Inc. (AAP): A Bull Case Theory
Economy

Advance Auto Parts, Inc. (AAP): A Bull Case Theory

June 10, 2025
Gundlach says to buy international stocks on dollar’s ‘secular decline’
Economy

Gundlach says to buy international stocks on dollar’s ‘secular decline’

June 10, 2025
US oil output set for first annual drop since pandemic
Economy

US oil output set for first annual drop since pandemic

June 10, 2025
logo logo
Facebook Twitter Youtube

About US


Explore global affairs, political insights, and linguistic origins. Stay informed with our comprehensive coverage of world news, politics, and Lifestyle.

Top Categories
  • Crime
  • Environment
  • Sports
  • Tech and Science
Usefull Links
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • DMCA

© 2024 americanfocus.online –  All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?