A recent poll conducted by the Association for a Better New York revealed that nearly 90% of New York City voters support expanding involuntary commitment and care for mentally ill residents who are roaming the streets or the subway. The findings come at a time when Governor Kathy Hochul is pushing for changes in the involuntary commitment laws, facing resistance in the legislature.
The survey, which included 600 voters, showed overwhelming support for expanding treatment, with only 4% opposed and 8% undecided. The majority of voters from all parts of the city and various demographic groups expressed support for the proposed changes.
In addition to supporting expanded treatment, 91% of voters agreed that it is more compassionate to provide involuntary treatment and care for people with severe mental illness than to leave them on the streets. A similar percentage also agreed that individuals struggling with severe mental illness should not be denied life-saving psychiatric care due to their inability to recognize the need for help.
The poll highlighted concerns about public safety incidents involving individuals with untreated severe mental illness, with 73% of voters stating that the number of such incidents has increased in recent years. This has led to a growing sense of unease among New Yorkers, particularly in the transit system.
Despite overwhelming public support for the proposed changes, Governor Hochul is facing challenges in getting the legislation passed in Albany. The state Assembly and Senate have presented counter proposals to the governor’s budget plan, omitting or altering key aspects of the involuntary commitment expansion.
While some mental health advocates and civil activists oppose forced treatment, others, including Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, have expressed openness to finding acceptable compromises to address the issue. Heastie emphasized the need for subway safety and preventing public spaces from becoming temporary shelters for individuals with mental health issues.
Overall, the survey conducted by Tulchin Research for ABNY reflects a widespread belief among voters that involuntary care is both compassionate and necessary for those who cannot care for themselves. As discussions continue in Albany, the focus remains on finding solutions that prioritize both the well-being of individuals with severe mental illness and public safety.
