A soldier who threatened an army captain with death during a late-night altercation, and referred to him using derogatory language, has lost both his name suppression and military rank.
Following a court martial at Linton Military Camp near Palmerston North on Friday, acting Corporal Jared Joseph Deal was demoted to the rank of sapper and received a reprimand.
The 31-year-old was found guilty of threatening to kill and using insulting language towards a superior during an incident that occurred late on December 6, 2024, after a cocktail party at Waiouru Military Camp.
Deal was acquitted of a charge of using violence against a superior, which involved allegations that he headbutted the captain during an argument over a disputed kiss earlier that year.
According to Deal’s partner, the captain had made an unwanted advance by kissing her following a formal dinner, while the captain claimed that she had kissed him.
Both Deal’s partner and the captain have been granted name suppression, along with several other witnesses, due to security concerns or their deployment with the Defence Force.
‘Profound effect’
The captain, in a victim impact statement, expressed feeling unsettled by the incident, which took place at the end of a celebratory evening for officer cadets.
Deal and the captain encountered each other while heading home.
“The threat to kill has had a profound effect on my sense of personal safety,” the captain’s statement indicated. “Before this incident, I did not perceive myself to be at significant risk from another member of the NZ Defence Force.
“The incident has left me feeling less secure, more vigilant, and more aware of potential threats to myself and those around me.”
The captain noted that such incidents undermine the cohesion essential to the military environment.
Suppression lifted
Deal sought to maintain his name suppression, but Judge Gerard Winter decided to lift the interim order.
During the sentencing, the defence highlighted Deal’s generally commendable record over his 12-year military career.
He excelled in rugby, representing the Defence Force at three World Cups, and had connections with the Manawatū Turbos representative team and played sevens for Manawatū.
Deal now coaches the Manawatū sevens team and is involved in mentoring Defence Force athletes.
A carpenter by profession, earlier this year he led a flood-recovery team in Hicks Bay, helping restore the area’s sole general store. It was also disclosed that he had a prior assault conviction from a military tribunal related to an incident in Niue in 2022.
Deal explained that he and others were convicted after they restrained a drunken soldier to prevent chaos.
Judge Winter stated that he and the military panel disregarded this conviction.
Deal also had a previous insubordination conviction related to confronting an officer who was bullying a recruit during basic training.
Since the prosecution started, Deal has sought counseling for anger management and has worked on his communication skills, including addressing his tendency for “extended monologues” and “hyperbolic language,” as noted by a counselor.
Deal expressed to the court that he is a “very proud soldier.”
Defense lawyer Deborah Davies argued that the incident could have been avoided if Deal had just walked away upon seeing the officer at Waiouru.
Since the prosecution began, Deal has missed out on a deployment to Antarctica, been banned from playing representative rugby for the Defence Force, and had a permanent promotion to corporal put on hold.
“This was a momentary lapse in judgment by an otherwise good soldier during a heightened off-duty situation at night,” Davies said.
Soldier lost discipline
Judge Winter noted that military courts operate differently from civilian ones, emphasizing the importance of discipline and cohesion within the Defence Force, and the necessity for personnel to consistently demonstrate integrity.
“During the confrontation, you lost discipline, became angry, and yelled at [the captain], ‘I will f…… kill you, c…’,” the judge told Deal.
Deal showed no remorse for his actions, which included making “low-level gutter insults in anger.”
“You lost discipline,” the judge reiterated. “You succumbed to anger.
“Threatening a superior officer in such a deliberate manner is absolutely unacceptable.”
Â
