This past week marked a significant moment in science advocacy on several fronts. The Union of Concerned Scientists introduced their Science Rising initiative (watch the kickoff), uniting many in the scientific community to stand against the Trump administration’s actions perceived as attacks on science. Simultaneously, a draft rule from the White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB), referred to as the Uniform Grants Regulation, has sparked strong opposition from the scientific community. This rule proposes changing how federal research funding is distributed, granting Trump administration appointees veto power over funding decisions that do not align with their priorities.
Following an initial outcry from experts closely monitoring this rule, major institutions and prominent figures in the science community have issued responses. Thousands have engaged in learning how to respond, and scientists and supporters are preparing to submit public comments opposing the proposal. Efforts are underway to extend the comment period, with OMB expected to receive a substantial volume of public input on their controversial draft rule.
We need this unity beyond the OMB rule
The scientific community’s unified response to this proposal, which threatens to disrupt the federal science research infrastructure, is inspiring. This infrastructure has been instrumental in fostering scientific progress, economic growth, and global leadership in science for the country.
The OMB proposal is not the first challenge to science and scientists during the second Trump term. The administration’s approach to dismantling the US scientific research apparatus, and the way research is used or ignored in policy decisions, has significant implications for communities worldwide. The dismissal of key experts, rollback of federal investments in underserved communities, and undermining of protections against political interference in science are all critical issues.
The strong collective response to the OMB rule highlights the power of unity and collaboration. The scientific community should apply this same energy to broader attacks on science and democracy affecting communities nationwide.
Signs of bravery in a culture of fear
Amid ongoing fear and hesitancy within parts of the scientific community to criticize the administration, such solidarity is crucial.
Recently, at the American Diabetes Association’s annual meeting in New Orleans, police expelled five scientists for distributing an editorial criticizing the Trump administration’s influence on the National Institutes of Health (NIH), ahead of a keynote by NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya. These researchers were sharing information about the NIH’s shortcomings in fulfilling its promises to the communities it serves, including those living with diabetes. The editorial is available online, yet their peaceful and evidence-based criticism led to their expulsion by armed officers.
This act of censorship has a chilling effect on those willing to speak out about ongoing harms. Unfortunately, this incident is not isolated; it is one of many where the science community has opted for silence or compliance when faced with opportunities to address the Trump administration’s actions. Scientific leaders and institutions need to support, not stifle, those demonstrating bravery.
Now is the time for courage
It’s time to act courageously. There are numerous issues deserving our sustained collective effort. You can join the Science Rising Action Corps and hold Congress accountable for protecting science and democracy. Urge elected officials to fund FEMA for disaster protection, pass the Scientific Integrity Act to shield federal scientists from political interference, safeguard climate research centers, preserve the US Forest Service, and close nuclear weapons loopholes.
Encourage your community to protest Trump administration policies. Join the UCS Science Network to learn the best ways to engage with officials. Explore creating and supporting independent scientific structures. Speak up in your social and professional circles, support your neighbors, and clearly express your values.
This week demonstrates our potential. Let’s continue moving forward.
