The economic landscape in China is facing challenges as consumer spending remains stagnant. Despite discounts of 80% or 70% on clothes in supermarkets, Chinese consumers are showing little inclination to spend due to various factors affecting their disposable income and overall financial well-being.
A recent report by Jeremy Stevens, an Asia economist at Standard Bank, highlighted that disposable income growth in China has halved since the onset of the pandemic in 2020. With wages in most sectors failing to keep up with GDP growth, the overall labor market is showing signs of contraction, especially in the face of U.S. tariffs impacting factories.
A survey conducted by the People’s Bank of China revealed that a record high of 64% of Chinese households preferred saving money over spending or investing in the third quarter of 2024. This trend continued into the fourth quarter, with more than 60% of respondents opting to save. The preference for saving is deeply rooted in Chinese culture, where limited insurance coverage requires individuals to bear the bulk of expenses for healthcare, education, and retirement.
To stimulate spending, economists suggest increasing pension payouts, introducing public holidays, and offering consumption vouchers in the services sector. However, Chinese policymakers have refrained from mass cash handouts, unlike their counterparts in the U.S. and Hong Kong post-pandemic.
The shift towards lower-priced products and migration from tier 1 cities like Shanghai and Beijing to tier 3 and 4 cities is impacting consumer behavior. Smaller cities are experiencing higher growth in the sale of daily necessities, offsetting declines in tier 1 cities. As consumers prioritize affordability, businesses are responding with increased promotions and lower prices.
The impact of these trends is evident even in sectors like flower sales, where increased demand from less affluent cities is driving higher volumes but lower average selling prices. The disparity in income levels between urban and rural areas further underscores the challenges facing consumer spending in China.
Analysts predict a slow recovery in retail sales, with May’s year-on-year growth expected to dip slightly from April. As Chinese consumers become more discerning and rational in their spending habits, the road to economic recovery may be a long and challenging one for policymakers and businesses alike. According to the latest data from the St. Louis Fed, the average income in China is far less than the reported $64,474 in the United States as of December. This discrepancy in income levels is a reflection of the economic disparities between the two countries.
Standard Bank’s analyst, Stevens, highlighted that the ratio of consumption to income in rural areas of China has significantly increased, surpassing pre-pandemic levels. However, urban households have experienced a decline in this ratio. It is important to note that lower-income households lack the wealth accumulation of higher-income groups, making it challenging for them to significantly boost consumption in the near future.
Stevens also pointed out that the top 20% of income earners in China account for half of total income and consumption, as well as 60% of total savings. This disparity underscores the need for structural wage reforms and policy support for low-income groups. Despite the well-meaning intentions behind China’s “common prosperity” rhetoric, Stevens noted that institutional realignments and policy shifts have added to the existing uncertainty in the economy.
The ongoing changes in China’s economic landscape, coupled with the push for common prosperity, have yet to fully reach a new equilibrium. It is crucial for policymakers to address the income inequality and consumption disparities in order to achieve sustainable economic growth and prosperity for all segments of society.
For more insights and analysis on Asia’s largest economy, subscribe to our weekly newsletter. Stay informed about the latest developments and trends shaping the Chinese economy.
